AuguryUK watchdog opens wide-ranging consultation on crypto investment rules — what firms and traders should expect
This article was written by the Augury Times
What the FCA launched and why it matters now
The UK’s financial regulator has put a new discussion paper into the market asking firms, investors and the wider crypto industry for their views on how digital assets should sit inside the country’s investment rules. The paper covers a broad set of questions — from whether some tokens should be treated like traditional investments, to rules for custody, disclosure and how retail customers should be allowed to buy crypto products.
Why this matters: the consultation could change which tokens are allowed to be sold to ordinary investors, raise the bar for exchanges and custodians operating in the UK, and force issuers to disclose more about reserves and governance. That will affect trading venues, token listings and the funds that package crypto for investors—so price and flow changes are a real possibility even before final rules land.
What the discussion paper asks and which parts of the market it targets
The paper does not set new law today. Instead it asks a long list of questions designed to draw out practical options for future regulation. Key themes the FCA is asking about include:
- How to define which digital assets look and act like investments — and so sit inside the FCA’s perimeter.
- What disclosure and governance standards token issuers should meet if their tokens are treated as investment products.
- Standards for custody and segregation when firms hold client assets, including minimum safeguards and proof-of-reserves practices.
- Rules governing trading venues and token listings, including who should be allowed to list tokens and the checks required before a token is offered to UK customers.
- How stablecoins should be treated where they are used as a payment or as an investment, including reserve transparency and operational resilience.
- Suitability and distribution rules for retail investors — whether some tokens should be restricted to professional clients.
In scope are tokens that resemble securities or investment contracts, trading platforms and custodians serving UK customers, asset managers offering tokenised funds, and stablecoin issuers whose products are used within the UK financial system. The consultation frames these as policy options rather than fixed definitions, and asks for evidence and practical detail from market participants.
How the paper could shift markets, liquidity and tradability
Even at the consultation stage, the proposals contain clear channels that could move prices and flows if they become policy. Expect at least three market effects:
First, tighter listing and custody rules would raise the cost of doing business for exchanges and custodians. That could narrow margins for smaller venues and encourage migration to larger, regulated platforms — a tailwind for big public exchanges and custody providers, and a headwind for niche venues.
Second, clearer classification rules could force some tokens out of the retail market or into a different product wrapper. Tokens deemed to be investment-like may face stricter disclosure or be sold only to professional clients, which would reduce retail liquidity and could depress prices for weaker tokens.
Third, stablecoin requirements on reserves and auditability would affect issuers’ funding costs and trust in certain coins. Any hit to the perceived safety of a widely used stablecoin could ripple through trading pairs, margin calls and short-term liquidity across exchanges.
Companies with large public footprints — for example Coinbase (COIN) on the exchange side and big asset managers that have started crypto products such as BlackRock (BLK) — will be watching closely. They stand to benefit from clearer rules but will also face compliance costs and possible interruptions to product availability.
How the industry is likely to respond — flashpoints to watch
Expect the industry to split along predictable lines. Exchanges and custodians will press for clear, practical rules that avoid stifling innovation. Asset managers want a workable regime for tokenised funds and custody safe-harbors. Stablecoin issuers and payments firms will push back on overly prescriptive reserve rules that could complicate liquidity management.
Key flashpoints will include token classification (what counts as an investment), the scale of disclosure and audit requirements for issuers, and whether UK rules diverge sharply from the EU or US regimes. Smaller firms are likely to warn against one-size-fits-all rules that raise fixed costs and favour big incumbents.
The consultation timetable and what to track next
The FCA has opened the consultation now and is inviting written responses. The paper sets out a formal response window that runs for several weeks, with the deadline for submissions expected around February–March 2026. After responses are reviewed, the regulator will publish feedback and next steps, which could include draft rules or further targeted consultations through 2026 and into 2027.
Investors should watch three milestones: the consultation deadline, the FCA’s response paper, and any draft rule or statutory instrument that signals binding changes.
Practical steps for investors and crypto firms to prepare
For investors
- Assess exposure: identify holdings in tokens with thin liquidity, unclear governance or unproven reserves. These are the most likely to lose value or face sale restrictions under new rules.
- Watch signals: major delistings, exchange license refusals, or audited reserve shortfalls for popular stablecoins are triggers that would prompt active portfolio moves.
- Consider position sizing: a precautionary reduction in leverage and a bias toward well-established tokens and exchange-traded products can lower sudden liquidity risk.
For crypto firms and fund managers
- Review custody and segregation arrangements now and document practices that show client asset protection.
- Prepare clearer disclosures for token economics, governance and reserve practices — even if not yet required, this will speed approvals and reassure investors.
- Model compliance costs and potential product changes if retail access is restricted for some tokens; factor that into commercial plans and pricing.
In short, this consultation is a major step toward bringing more of the crypto market into the UK’s investment rulebook. The detailed outcomes will take time to land, but the path is now clearer: firms and investors who act early to shore up custody, disclosures and liquidity plans will be better placed when the rules arrive.
Photo: Thought Catalog / Pexels
Sources